Advertising Strategies of Mystic Organisations
Jagrat Jaggi1, Hari Kaushik N2
1MBA in Symbiosis Institute of Management Studies, Khadki, Pune.
2PGADM in Real Estate and Construction Management, Symbiosis, Pune.
*Corresponding Author E-mail: jagrat.jaggi2020@sims.edu
ABSTRACT:
The present contemporary social orders are confronting issues like household manhandle, brutality, wrongdoing, medicate dependence, verbal forcefulness, suicide and so on at the individual level and poor work propensities, affront for specialists, worker attack, inappropriate behavior, absence of restraint and introverted threats at the expert level. In spite of such disasters the present age is so exceptionally led and roused by otherworldly pioneers Spirituality blows in the breezes of India yet now daily's unique profound pioneers with various promoting techniques are emerging in the skyline. Spirituality has turned into the most supported administration given by the profound masters separated from the national limits and religion. It is our heart that empowers us to separate between great or terrible, correct, guided by our interior intentions and driving forces, sentiments and feelings sustained by convictions, values and other a few elements. Initially, identified themes namely Marketing and branding in the spiritual organization, Effective promotional tools, Spiritual Leaders and Marketing Techniques and found papers suited to this theme. Around 33 papers are shortlisted and went through them and that built our road on this paper. Identified few gaps during the literature review on the lines of not getting a lot of time for the research, if got the time, the paper would have been a little better. A very few papers which only few focused on this topic. Hence, the resources were short. The present paper looks at the significance of Spirituality and endeavored to distinguish a portion of the promoting methodologies received by profound advertisers and associations.
KEYWORDS: Spiritual, Strategy, Marketing, Mystic Organisations, Thematic review, Systematic literature review.
1. INTRODUCTION:
Spirituality as a word cannot be defined, it has various connotations for different people. But yes, there is a general consensus among masses for it. The largely accepted definition of spirituality believes that, there is a higher entity that looks onto the universe and takes care of the well-being of the society. There are constant efforts to find a path to that entity, a constant search to find meaning to this life and that is only possible if you find the path to that entity.
This search to that entity is slowly transforming into a blind race. This race is leading to the rise of organizations which claim to have found that path and selling that path to the general masses. This is creating the rise of blind faith in these organizations, and flourishing their business (Kumar, 2014). These organizations are also feeding on the fear factor of the general masses. Fear factor comes into play when people suffering from any kind of illness or difficult times are told the only way to be cured it to make that divine power happy, and that is the only way to their wellness.
Indians known for their economical purchasing propensities wind up liberal on those purchases that can associate them to the perfect or possibly offer potential outcomes of the divine entity which is believed in. Take a gander at the way religious celebrations and social traditions prompt the spending binge. The outlook is by all accounts influencing an ever-increasing number of individuals. Religion and other worldliness could be the following huge thought that may bring ventures and see new companies hold up.
Being one of the biggest disorderly fragments in the nation, numerous gauge this to develop to someplace around $30 billion by the following couple of years. A basic research on an example of approximately 500 Hindu families did by a forthcoming entrepreneurial wander assessed only the Delhi/NCR market to be at around $35 million for each annum. That was just about pujas, standard ceremonies, religious celebrations and some yearly watched religious practices (Abela., 2014).
In the event that the whole
extent of subjects like relational unions, housewarmings, customs identified
with births and passing’s, intermittent family pujas and merriments, crystal
gazing and fortune swinging practices is incorporated, the quantum of the
market may develop a complex. Indeed, journeys and religious tourism may
likewise shape a piece of this. Envision the business opportunity that might be
there for a one-stop shop or an application that gives bundled answers for such
religion-otherworldly needs (King., 2004).
From this it is evident that how easy it is in India to gain popularity as a
spiritual leader. India breeds some of richest spiritual leaders of the world.
The research would talk about what marketing strategies these leaders adopt and
how they target and attack on the weak spots of the audience. It would also highlight,
what external factors apart from advertising strategies help them to flourish
in India.
2. SYSTEMATIC LITERATURE REVIEW METHODOLOGY:
The general guidelines followed in the literature review in management is at times condemned for being one-sided and lacking real figures. The rules which are appeared beneath presents the extent of this review, the procedures used to distinguish the relevant literature and the papers which are incorporated into this review.
2.1 Scope of the review:
The extent of this review is characterized by two arrangements of criteria identifying with content and form. As far as form, this survey incorporates scholastic research articles by writers (J Kumar, 2014) and it rejects book sections and additionally non-scholastic articles, comprising of short magazine articles, perspectives, meetings, and publications. Regarding content, the focal point of this audit is on the spiritual leader usage of fame to grow their business in the country, particularly in connection to the showcasing and advertising fields.
2.2 Identification of relevant literature:
The procedure of writing relevant literature was led in one stage on 20 July 2018. In the principal stage, we searched down different combinations of the keywords ‘spirituality’, ’marketing’, ‘growth’, in five databases: Scopus, Ebsco, emerald insights, science direct, google scholar. These databases were picked in view of the measure of value and quality. The academic substance they give and also their pertinence to administration and research in business. The information extracted from these databases incorporated the articles title, publication of the year, journal and the type of document. At the point when searched from the given keyword the databases results of around 579 papers, which was further refined to 196 results. 383 papers were removed which include duplicates and few irrelevant papers. It was decided to exclude papers which included spiritual organizations as money making organization (Sullivan K.R., Delaney H., 2018). The articles having how spiritual organizations manipulate people were also removed (Haq f., 2011), (Al-Hyari K., 2013). We also removed the papers that had any specific religion literature (Jafari A, 2016).
The papers which had use of use of spirituality and its use in social media were also removed (Social Happiness: Theory into Policy and Practice, 2011). The articles which marginally explored the topic were removed as well (Lee S.), (M, 2009).
The final search for any literature was done once more on the reading university website, just to check if any more relevant literature was left. Database screening brought about 579 records, of which 383 copies were distinguished and removed, bringing about 196 one of a kind records (see Table 1 for the definite database convention). At last number of 33 articles were held for consideration in this survey. The procedure of the first phase of the systematic literature review is outlined in Figure 2.
2.3 Systematic literature review results:
The 1196 final articles (Figure 1). were published in the years between 2001-2018 from which 33 articles were discovered and shortlisted. (Figure 3). There is a steady increase in the number of articles published, the reason is on the lines that this was the time when spirituality started to rise. This was time when spiritual leader started to make it a business and eventually turned into organizations.
Table 1. Database search protocol
|
Databases |
Scope and search criteria |
Date of search |
Number of items |
|
EBSCO discovery service
|
Search: Journals Abstracts, Keywords Language: English |
20-07-2018 |
79 |
|
Google scholar |
Search: Journals, Articles Abstracts, Keywords Language: English |
20-07-2018 |
80 |
|
Science direct |
Search: Journals, Articles Abstracts, Keywords Language: English |
20-07-2018 |
387 |
|
Scopus |
Search: Journals Abstracts, Keywords Language: English |
20-07-2018 |
20 |
|
Emerald insights |
Search: Journals Abstracts, Keywords Language: English |
20-07-2018 |
13 |
|
Total |
|
|
579 |
Figure 1: Number of total aggregate of articles in the review and by and large research done as on 20 July 2018.
Figure 2: 1st phase of the systematic literature review process is shown by the Flow chart
Figure 3: Number of included articles in the review by the year of publications
3. METHODOLOGICAL REVIEW:
The present examination is a subjective research and spotlights on interdisciplinary record of religious customer society and in addition to the individual and authoritative impacts on them. It coordinates and systematizes commitments from the financial aspects of religion, promoting, and human science of religion. The information is gathered from essential and auxiliary sources.
The data is assembled by suggesting the present investigation is a qualitative research and spotlights on interdisciplinary record of the societal causes and also individual and authoritative impacts of religious customer society. It incorporates and systematizes commitments from the financial aspects of religion, showcasing, and human science of religion. Primary and secondary sources are used to collect the data. The data collected through secondary sources is by referring to A case of Patanjali Yogpeeth because they had undergone critical review by writers, and it avoids book sections and additionally non-scholastic articles and by alluding to five databases: Scopus, Ebsco, insights, science direct, google scholar. The information gathered through different exchanges and sources are altogether investigated to separate the important data out of that.
Non-Empirical research strategies were utilized as a part of 45.45% of the surveyed articles (n = 15), trailed by Qualitative methodologies in 21.21% of the papers (n = 7), quantitative techniques utilized in 18.18% of the articles (n = 6), and mixed techniques in 15.15% of the writing (n = 5) (Table 2). This methodological discontinuity can be clarified by the assortment of subjects and research questions explored in the investigated articles, and the differing levels of examination.
The predominance of non-exact and subjective methodologies in the inspected writing The advancement of advertising is investigated from the materiality of the business exchanges of procurement and offer of items and administrations, to the immaterial perspectives inalienable to the value-based process, in light of scholarly capital and estimations of profound nature (Marques, 2018) With regards to another cosmogony, the creators close on the choosing part of the immaterial resources of associations keeping in mind the end goal to make their upper hand, in light of the ideas of significant worth, fulfillment, trust, and client faithfulness.
Table 2. Reviewed literature and the Research methodologies used.
|
|
Number of Articles |
Percentage |
|
Non-Empirical |
15 |
45.46 % |
|
Qualitative |
7 |
21.21 % |
|
Quantitative |
6 |
18.18 % |
|
Mixed Techniques |
5 |
15.15 % |
|
Total |
33 |
100 % |
4. THEMATIC REVIEW:
The primary topics of research in the looked into writing were recognized after precisely looking at the watchwords and digests of the 33 articles, before perusing their full messages to create a rundown of repeating topics. Therefore, Marketing and branding in the spiritual organization was observed to be the best subject of research with 12 articles, trailed by 8 articles on Effective promotional tools, followed by Spiritual Leaders with 8 articles and Marketing Techniques with 5 articles (Figure 4). This examination introduces the reasons for religious purchaser society and the most incessant individual adjustments (quality desires, religious shopping, syncretism) and authoritative reactions (showcasing and marking methodologies) This literature is just a small insights and impression of the present practices inside organizations and of the discussions brought up in the professional writing.
Figure 4: Main themes of the research paper done.
4.1 Marketing and branding in the spiritual organization:
In 12 articles on the themes identified with branding and marking in the spiritual organization were the best territory of examination in the assessed writing to have the capacity to profit other individuals and his general surroundings. (Shaw D., 2013). Some of the time, it is trusted that spirituality and religion are same, yet it ought to be noticed that spirituality and religion are two distinct terms and regarded as two unique builds in considers completed in past (Bakar A., 2013). Nonetheless, spirituality has been talked about by thinking about measurement of yoga and pranayam into it (Melo R., 2017). The word Yoga has been gotten from a Sanskrit word 'yuj', which intends to accomplish the objective of salvation through physical and mental adjust (Lee Y.-S., 2015). On one hand, yoga helps in fortifying body and brain, however then again, it is likewise a business and results in change of utilization conduct of individuals. By and large, individuals pick some profound master for honing yoga in this way the otherworldly masters have their own particular significance in India. A great many individuals, from India as well as from outside nations, are following the profound masters for spirituality illumination. Spirituality masters are not just changing conduct of mass populace yet in addition bringing about changing utilization conduct. Promoting through spirituality additionally manages change in utilization conduct because of spirituality (Lakshmi J.K., 2015). Here, in the present paper, most importantly, the reasonable connection of spirituality and promoting is examined through survey of writing and the system of the present examination is expressed. Also, the contextual investigation of on this is viewed as and colossal base of the association is uncovered in its presentation.
4.2 Effective promotional tools:
In 8 articles on the themes identified with effective promotional tools, it incorporates and systematizes commitments from financial matters of religion, advertising, and humanism of religion (Moal-Ulvoas G., 2014). The article introduces the reasons for religious purchaser society and the most successive individual adjustments (quality desires, religious shopping, syncretism) and authoritative reactions (showcasing and marking techniques). Discoveries are that (1) in the religious buyer society, people are free not to be religious or spirituality, putting religious relationship in rivalry with common associations, and conceivably prompting secularization, (2) it is overstated to discuss shopping and devouring as the "new religions" of Western social orders, and (3) religious showcasing and marking face vital impediments, some interior and some outside to religious and profound associations, because of the difficulty between promoting hones and supernatural cases (T., 2012). Let’s take case of Yoga hones help to keep up a sound living of physical, mental, and profound resources (Rentschler R., 2012). Diverse yogic stances keep our body in an appropriate condition by normalizing circulatory strain, cholesterol levels, and boosting the safe framework. Along these lines, it is required to advertise yoga benefits by executing legitimate limited time apparatuses in the present situation. Relationship promoting sets up solid social, monetary, and specialized ties with clients (Robinson T.D., 2016). It diminishes the exchange time and related expenses. It makes a commonly productive business connection amongst clients and specialist organizations. Commencement for yoga advancement is to be bolstered with relationship advertising as powerful special instrument for supportable improvement of the yoga showcase. The motivation behind this examination was to analyse the effect of relationship promoting on client faithfulness in the yoga part. Keeping up the client dependability in the yoga area is imperative to pull in new potential clients in urban India to satisfy clients' desires identified with their medicinal services. Client can be expanded by receiving distinctive huge methodologies in yoga advancement through relationship promoting. Comprehension of client conduct in the relationship-building procedure of a yoga association is critical to hold and pull in potential clients (Kim D., 2018). This examination concentrated on the impacts of various factors in the relationship-building process on client reliability with regards to yoga advertising in urban India (Dushan Chaminda J.W., 2014). This investigation accentuated the advertising writing on the relationship improvement show for client benefits.
4.3 Spiritual Leaders:
In 8 articles on the themes identified with spiritual leaders, consequently, we can characterize spiritual leader as, the individual who move certainty and support among the general population through correspondence process who are in fact to accomplish spirituality. Profound administration accentuates on relationship administration between the pioneer and the general population being driven. Most meaning of initiative mirror the presumption that it includes a procedure whereby purposeful impact is applied by individual over others to guide, structure and encourage exercises and connections in a gathering or association. Impact is the embodiment of administration and great pioneers substantially affect the lives of devotees (Dai F., 2017). State of mind of adherents towards the pioneer shows pioneer's adequacy. How well does the pioneer fulfil their requirements and desires? Do adherents like appreciate and regard the pioneer, however administration style of Spiritual and corporate pioneers looks like to some degree yet they are essentially extraordinary in moving toward supporters.
4.4 Marketing Techniques:
In 5 articles on the themes identified with marketing techniques, spiritual marketing do takes after every one of the systems or standards took after for a typical item or administration (David Lee J., 2016). E.g., we can see enormous and general flex sheets of profound battles and Gurus like some other item to make mindfulness in the mass open. Regardless of it have some additional modes to pull in the potential clients. Therefore, adjustment is required in the instructor. The general thought is to show an otherworldly picture of the instructor to the client with the goal that the specialist of the lessons isn't questioned:
1. Psychosomatic Transfer: Gurus are expanded at the highest point of the spirituality range, a dignitary with forces to impact the life of his adherents decidedly.
2. Fashion and style: introduction as a profound instructor is imperative. Standpoint of the pioneer needs to fit with the desires for the intended interest group.
3. Name adjustment: Names are the impression of the kind of profound instructor. Changing name to a fascinating sounding one is critical in introduction of a profound ace. Customary names don't convey an indistinguishable weight from something like "Shivananda" or "Atmananda".
4. Behaviour: Spiritual individuals are by and large viewed as exceptionally tranquil and cherishing, and calm.
5. Vocabulary: Spirituality has its own vocabulary. Vocabulary of otherworldly pioneers is not quite the same as different pioneers. They utilization of fascinating words or manner to gain a focused edge on rest.
6. Narcissism: Certain measure of narcissism in conduct of such pioneers improves their fearlessness and magnetism. Certainty, Charisma and a solid comical inclination are the devices to change and pull in the clients.
7. Comprehensive Teaching Materials and Opportunities: recordings, addresses and address accounts, guided contemplations, books, web updates and end of the week courses and occasion withdraws in outlandish areas, are the most lucrative advertising techniques received by profound advertisers. A month to month bulletin (both paper and on the web) or even magazine, satsangs and so forth are additionally used to keep people in contact.
8. Educational/Charitable Foundation: This procedure chips away at to set up a picture of a genuine well-wisher and do-gooder of mankind and propels individuals to help the great aim and the advancement of the entire planet.
9. Ashram or Spiritual Centre: This adds believability to the association
10. Website: It is currently indispensable for any 21st Century ace to have a web nearness.
11. Auxiliary Sales: It isn't simply lessons are advertised, pictures, pendants, key chains and different things saturated with Gurus enthusiastic profound vibrations and endowments are additionally made accessible to supporters.
12. Reward slavish Followers: Keep telling the most enthusiastic supporters how incredibly they are getting along on the otherworldly way to bolster their profound self-images.
13. A Promise of Bliss, Health and Happiness: The last goal of the otherworldly way is a condition of unceasing ecstasy, idealize wellbeing and magnificent joy — illumination. A great many people begin following the profound way when they wind up baffled and miserable with typical life. Perhaps they are unwell or possibly they have experienced awful encounters.
14. Special/Secret Teachings and Techniques: This is exceptionally appealing system to draw in the potential clients (devotees), that they will just discover arousing in the event that they take after these specific lessons/methods. This secures them to pioneer emphatically.
15. Freedom of passionate articulation: Any training that energizes free enthusiastic articulation can be extremely appealing and liberating.
16. Testimonial for Teachings: Spiritual showcasing resembles some other sort of advertising; advertisers utilize tributes and contextual investigations for the media to advance a specific otherworldly instructing and instructor. With the ascent of person to person communication, this frequently happens immediately.
17. Chronological lessons: Spirituality would never be accomplished arbitrarily. It is a consecutive long-lasting learning process.
18. Pseudo-Scientific Justification: lessons are connected with present day material science as it truly increases believably of saying. Terms like "quantum", "relativity", "scalar waves", "quantum trap", "Ringer's Theorem" and "photons "imply the way that adage has been "demonstrated" by quantum material science and other related science.
5. LIMITATIONS:
There are two fundamental impediments to this review. The primary constraint relates to the chosen keywords. In spite of the fact that our keyword blends were intended to be expansive and inclusive and the extent of looking through the writing included titles, catchphrases, and edited compositions at whatever point material, some applicable writing may have been ignored. The second confinement of this audit relates to the danger of inclination in including and barring articles, even with the predefined criteria. Spirituality joins psyche, body and soul and Commercialization of spirituality is the most pessimistic part of the most intrinsic and customized sentiments. Burning through cash realizes desire required outcomes and the genuine feeling of spirituality is out of a desire, it is the individual experience fluctuating individual to individual. Dedication does not expect and emotions can't be evaluated. Combination of self to preeminent self is over a wide range of advertising, methods, inspiration and so forth. Polished methodology of mysticism has deglorified its fact and reality. Need of self-conviction and commitment are self-expressed. This adventure of looking about self, begins and closures at self as it were. Dogmatism is another impediment to achieve spiritual realization. Religious ideas are more moderate instead of dynamic prompting errors by and large. Spiritual experiences are close to home and by and large can't be disclosed to its real statures. They are ageless, indescribable, stunning and astounding. Profound development drives towards undemanding adoration and administration past little self.
6. DIRECTIONS FOR FUTURE RESEARCH:
This article gives a working meaning of spirituality which can be utilized as a beginning stage for concentrate the wonder inside the showcasing setting. Researchers are urged to give elective definitions and to complete a discussion on the benefits and downsides of the different definitions. Basic to this talk ought to be a pledge to keep away from the spirituality/religion discussion with regards to definitions. It is intriguing to investigate the relates of spirituality with different factors, for example, identity, nationality, culture, and age. A few fascinating issues could be looked into. For instance, does the frequency of spirituality increment or lessening with monetary improvement? What are the worldwide full-scale inclines in spirituality and how might these patterns affect buyer conduct? What is the relationship amongst spirituality and shopper character? Is spirituality progressively utilized as a method for character conservation and as a response to deterritorialization? To completely fathom the spirituality marvel and to clarify its progression in the commercial centre would require significant research, both subjective and quantitative. Division models might be composed by fusing profound factors containing the two convictions and practices. As specified before, it is baffling that very few showcasing researchers are occupied with the theme of spirituality. Doctoral theses on spirituality are relatively incredible in the corridors of promoting the scholarly world. There is not really any academic research tending to the part of spirituality in the shopper decision process. These oversights are most likely owing to the submissive emphasis on isolating spirituality from different components of life. Given the lack of research on the theme of spirituality, plentiful openings exist for the individuals who wish to make their check in this energizing territory. A prescribed beginning stage would be to completely conceptualize the idea of spirituality furthermore, delimit its limits. Researchers will then need to devise worthy scales that measure spirituality. While endeavours have been made in the administration and social brain research writing to grow such scales, (Cornwell B., 2005), the instruments seem ailing in explanatory meticulousness and exhaustiveness. Starting today, spirituality is as yet a tricky build, and just a methodical program of request will give important and significant bits of knowledge.
7. CONCLUSION:
It appears the world is stricken by the spirituality and promoting scholastics are neglectful of this improvement. Therefore, marketing researchers are generally oblivious about what has achieved the resurgence of spirituality and how this improvement plays out in the commercial centre. Spirituality is progressively affecting the convictions and practices of buyers the world over. Profound inspirations are not just limited to the decision of a specific faction, master, or religion. Common corporate firms are progressively utilizing profound interests to recognize and bond with purchasers. The people group of advertising researchers needs to earnestly grasp and research the part of spirituality in present day utilization. Administration researchers have officially taken discernment of the criticalness of spirituality, as prove by the quantity of articles on working environment spirituality figuring routinely in contemporary administration diaries. Diary editors in the field of marketing could help quicken hypothesis advancement on spirituality and marketing by welcoming and distributing papers investigating spirituality. In conclusion and in agreement with (Agarwala R., 2018), Doing such will help us in closing the gap between hypothesis and practice.
8. REFERENCES:
1. Agarwala R., M. P. (2018). Religiosity and consumer behavior: a summarizing review. Journal of Management, Spirituality and Religion.
2. Andrew V. Abela. (2014). Appealing to the imagination: Effective and ethical marketing of religion, Journal of Business Research, Volume 67, Issue 2,2014, Pages 50-58, ISSN 0148-2963.
3. Arora, N., Singh, G., & Grewal, B. (2016). Impact of Spirituality on Consumer Perception creation and Preference of Products wsrt FMCG and Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. in Punjab. Journal of Marketing Vistas, 6(2).
4. Angela Gracia B. Cruz, Yuri Seo, Margo Buchanan-Oliver. (2017). Religion as a field of transcultural practices in multicultural marketplaces, Journal of Business Research, ISSN 0148-2963.
5. Al-Hyari K., A. M.-W. (2013). Religious beliefs and consumer behavior:From loyalty to boycotts.
6. Bakar A., L. R. (2013). The effects of religious symbols in product packaging on Muslim consumer responses. Australasian Marketing Journal.
7. B., S. (2015). Artists, antagonisms and the ney in the popularization of ‘Sufi Music’ in Turkey. European Journal of Cultural Studies.
8. Cornwell B., C. C. (2005). A cross-cultural study of the role of religion in consumers' ethical positions. International Marketing Review.
9. Dushan Chaminda J.W., R. N. (2014). Broadening the scope of ethical consumer behaviour: A study on five precepts of Buddhism. Human Rights and Ethics: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications.
10. Dai F., T. S. (2017). Network Marketing Businesses and Chinese Ethnicity Immigrants in Australia. Journal of Small Business Management.
11. David Lee J., B. A.-S. (2016). Sustainable and non-sustainable consumer behavior in young adults. Young Consumers.
12. Fromm I., N. B. (2007). International trade, consumer behavior and trust: Factors affecting agribusinesses in developing countries. International Food and Agribusiness Management Review.
13. Jafari A, S. A. (2016). Marketing and Consumption: Critical Perspectives on the Intersections.
14. Gupta S., M. N. (2010). US consumers’ perceptions of garments inspired by Indonesian culture. Journal of Global Fashion Marketing.
15. Haq f., W. H. (2011). Handbook of Islamic Marketing.
16. Kim D., A. A. (2018). Shifts in online consumer behavior: A preliminary investigation of the net generation. Journal of Theoretical and Applied Electronic Commerce Research.
17. King, R., & Carrette, J. (2004). Selling spirituality: The silent takeover of religion. Routledge.
18. Kumar, V., Jain, A., Rahman, Z., & Jain A. (2014). Marketing through spirituality: A case of Patanjali Yogpeeth. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 133, 481-490.
19. Lakshmi J.K., N. D. (2015). Cultural consonance, constructions of science and co-existence: A review of the integration of traditional, complementary and alternative medicine in low- and middle-income countries. Health Policy and Planning.
20. Lee S., S. P. (n.d.). Evangelical Innovators and the Spiritual Marketplace. Holy Mavericks, 2009.
21. Lee Y.-S., P. N. (2015). Christian spirituality and tourist motivations. Tourism Analysis.
22. Marques, M. (2018). The contribution of marketing 3.0 for the strategic management of competitive advantages of organizations: A methodological proposal. Handbook of research on strategic innovation management for improved competitive advantage, Pages 342-358.
23. Moal-Ulvoas G., T. V. (2014). The spiritual benefits of travel for senior tourists. Journal of Consumer Behaviour.
24. Mitchell M.A., M. R. (2001). Generation x and religion: Evaluating and improving existing distribution strategies. Journal of Nonprofit and Public Sector Marketing.
25. Melo R., G. R. (2017). Nature sports participation: Understanding demand, practice profile, motivations and constraints. European Journal of Tourism Research.
26. Rodriguez-Rad, C; Ramos-Hidalgo, E. Spirituality, consumer ethics, and sustainability: the marketing role of moral identity. Journal of Consumer Marketing. Country of Publication: UK., 35,1,51-63, Jan. 2018.
27. Robinson T.D., C. J. (2016). Dying to consume: Marketing and the existentialization of sustainability. Research in Consumer Behavior.
28. Rentschler R., J. U. (2012). Extending the theory of metaphor in marketing: The case of the art gallery. Journal of Marketing Management.
29. Shaw D., T. J. (2013). Consuming spirituality: The pleasure of uncertainty. European Journal of Marketing.
30. Stolz J., U. J.-C. (2018). Religions as brands? Religion and spirituality in consumer society. Journal of Management, Spirituality and Religion.
31. T., B. (2012). The modern concept of marketing, an islamic perspective. Journal of King Abdulaziz University, Islamic Economics.
32. Wilson J.A.J., H. S. (2013). Assessing the implications on performance when aligning customer lifetime value calculations with religious faith groups and afterlifetime values - A Socratic elenchus approach. International Journal of Business Performance Management.
33. Y., J. (2016). Investigating the influence of spirituality, environmental concern and ecological knowledge on consumers' green purchase intention. Purushartha.
Received on 18.10.2019 Modified on 30.11.2019
Accepted on 09.12.2019 © A&V Publications All right reserved
Asian Journal of Management. 2020; 11(1):73-80.
DOI: 10.5958/2321-5763.2020.00012.8